St. Paul was the 1st- and 2nd-half split-season winner. Under the split-season format, the team with the second-best full-season record becomes the other playoff contestant. As it happened, Winnipeg and Sioux Falls both had identical full-season records, so they played a one-game tiebreaker. Winnipeg won the game to advance to the championship playoff.
Visiting teams listed first, home teams second. Winning teams in bold.
9/5/95
Winnipeg W, Sioux City 4
9/6/95
Winnipeg 2, St. Paul 3
9/7/95
Winnipeg 6, St. Paul 4
9/8/95
St. Paul 2, Winnipeg 0
9/9/95
St. Paul 4, Winnipeg 0
MVP of series: Doug O'Neill (St. Paul)
I'm not sure of some of the scores (thus the W and L to denote simply winner and loser). If you know, please let me know.
[1993 Playoffs] [1994 Playoffs] [1995 Playoffs] [1996 Playoffs] [1997 Playoffs]
| 1993 | St. Paul |
| 1994 | Winnipeg |
| 1995 | St. Paul |
| 1996 | St. Paul |
| 1997 | Duluth-Superior |